OFFICIAL SPORTS SOURCESTHE STATE & NATION RELEASE ARCHIVE
THE SPORTS NEWS DESK
← MLB

MLB · ANALYSIS & OPINION

Baseball’s Last Ballot: Who Deserves the Hardware?

State & Nation predicts the 2026 MLB award winners, from MVP and Cy Young to the rookie races, relief honors and every Silver Slugger category.

The beautiful thing about baseball’s awards season is that nobody has to throw another pitch to start an argument.

Mention “most valuable” in a room full of baseball fans and somebody will reach for a batting average, somebody else will open an advanced-statistics page, and a third person will insist neither of them watched enough games.

All three might have a point.

An awards ballot asks us to weigh different kinds of greatness. How much does an extraordinary hitter need to produce to overcome the value of an excellent shortstop? When does a pitcher’s dominance outweigh another pitcher’s workload? And how do you measure a manager’s influence when the players ultimately have to execute?

With the 2026 hardware about to be handed out, here is where State & Nation lands.

Yordan Alvarez and Pete Crow-Armstrong are our MVP choices. Alvarez hit .316 with 42 home runs for Houston. Crow-Armstrong delivered 45 homers and 41 steals for Chicago, alongside outstanding defense.

The American League discussion deserves more thought than a quick glance at the home run column. Bobby Witt Jr. presents the kind of complete-player argument that should always receive serious consideration. Junior Caminero belongs in the conversation, too.

Our prediction is Alvarez. When evaluating a designated hitter, the offensive standard should be demanding. We believe he met it.

Crow-Armstrong is our more confident selection in the National League. The appeal of his candidacy is how little explaining it requires. Power, speed and defense all belong in a value discussion, and his season brings them together.

Shohei Ohtani deserves to have every part of his contribution considered. Brice Turang deserves recognition beyond the audience that follows Milwaukee every night. Our expectation, though, is that Crow-Armstrong takes home the trophy.

There is something healthy about judging each season on its own terms. An MVP ballot should never become a subscription that automatically renews.

Our Cy Young picks are Cam Schlittler in the American League and Jacob Misiorowski in the National League. Schlittler finished with a 1.95 ERA and 239 strikeouts; Misiorowski posted a 1.80 ERA and 252 strikeouts.

Pitching awards demand that we look beyond who happened to receive enough run support to collect a victory. A starter can control the quality of his pitches. He cannot control whether his teammates score six runs or spend the evening grounding into double plays.

Dylan Cease and Parker Messick give the AL ballot depth. Chris Sale and Cristopher Sánchez do the same in the NL. Our forecast favors Schlittler and Misiorowski because run prevention and strikeouts form such a persuasive combination.

These are two of our strongest predictions.

The rookie races require a little more willingness to live with uncertainty.

We are picking Detroit’s Kevin McGonigle in the American League and the Mets’ Carson Benge in the National League. Messick and Payton Tolle are McGonigle’s fellow finalists; Sal Stewart and JJ Wetherholt join Benge.

Our lean toward McGonigle reflects the value we place on an everyday contribution. That is a preference in a close comparison, not a rule that should shut pitchers out of consideration.

Benge gets our NL prediction for the balance of his offensive game. Stewart’s power makes him a particularly credible alternative.

Neither rookie pick comes with a victory lap attached. These are the ballots we would be least surprised to miss.

For Manager of the Year, we expect Kevin Cash and Pat Murphy to win. Cash’s Rays finished 98–64, while Murphy’s Brewers went 103–59.

Managerial voting can become an expectations contest. Take over a team people expect to lose, exceed those expectations and the narrative practically writes itself.

There is merit in that. Will Venable’s candidacy deserves serious attention, as does Chad Tracy’s. But excellence should remain eligible for recognition even when the manager has already demonstrated that he knows what he is doing.

Our preference is to reward the full regular-season achievement. Cash and Murphy are our choices on that basis.

In the bullpen, our predictions are Louis Varland and Mason Miller. Varland recorded a 1.27 ERA in 78 innings for Toronto. Miller struck out 129 batters in 70 innings for San Diego.

A save total is useful information. It also depends on how often a team supplies the right opportunity. We want a relief ballot to consider workload, dominance and the difficulty of the outs being recorded.

Bryan Baker and Cade Smith make the AL decision close. Miller is our firmer choice in the NL.

We predict the same pair will win the separate Mariano Rivera and Trevor Hoffman relief honors.

The rest of our individual-awards forecast has a familiar look: Alvarez and Crow-Armstrong for the Hank Aaron Awards, Alvarez for the Edgar Martinez Outstanding Designated Hitter Award and the AL Comeback Player honor, Zack Wheeler for NL Comeback Player, and Milwaukee’s Matt Arnold for Executive of the Year.

Those are predictions, not announced results. Wheeler’s return from thoracic outlet surgery is central to our comeback selection.

Then come the Silver Sluggers, where the assignment should stay refreshingly specific: judge the hitting.

Our American League picks are Carter Jensen at catcher, Pete Alonso at first, Kody Clemens at second, Bobby Witt Jr. at shortstop and Junior Caminero at third. In the outfield, we favor Randy Arozarena, Wilyer Abreu and Riley Greene, with Alvarez at DH and McGonigle at utility.

In the National League, our selections are Gabriel Moreno at catcher, Rafael Devers at first, Brandon Lowe at second, Elly De La Cruz at shortstop and Max Muncy at third. Our outfield is Crow-Armstrong, James Wood and Seiya Suzuki, followed by Kyle Schwarber at DH and Sal Stewart at utility. We predict the White Sox and Cubs will receive the offensive team awards. All are selections from the announced finalist fields.

Some of these calls will age better than others. That is the price of putting your name beneath a prediction before the envelope opens.

But a worthwhile awards column should do more than hedge until every possible result sounds like something it anticipated.

So there is our ballot: Alvarez and Crow-Armstrong at the top, Schlittler and Misiorowski on the mound, and a few close calls we are willing to defend.

The trophies will settle who won.

They have never settled the argument.

Sources

The State & NationOfficial sources. Original publications.

Independent aggregation with attribution to the issuing organization.

Media KitInstall app
Property of State and Nation Media Group LLC.