Opinion: FinCEN’s due-diligence proposal needs clear risk tests and workable identification
Treasury proposes fewer repetitive ownership checks alongside clearer identification rules. The balance depends on how institutions use additional information and handle legitimate customers.
FinCEN proposed changes November 17 to how covered financial institutions identify the beneficial owners of business and other legal-entity customers. Reducing repetitive checks is sensible, but the companion authority to request more information deserves a concrete risk rationale. A workable rule would improve the quality of ownership information without turning uncertainty about a customer into an automatic reason to deny service.
What the release says
The proposal would put existing FinCEN relief into the regulation: institutions would identify beneficial owners when a legal-entity customer first opens an account, when facts reasonably undermine the reliability of previously obtained ownership information, and as required by ongoing risk-based due diligence. It would not require a fresh identification exercise at every additional account opening. This part would codify relief already issued, rather than introduce an entirely new exemption today.
The linked fact sheet and proposed text also address additional information. Where other risk indicators or supervisory concerns warrant it, institutions could seek information relevant to lawful immigration status and employment authorization when assessing risks such as fraud, identity misrepresentation or sanctions evasion. That is conditional authority in a proposal, not a new universal immigration-document requirement for every account holder.
The proposal would specify identifying information about each beneficial owner and exclude an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number as a substitute for a Social Security number. The proposed text retains alternatives for non-U.S. persons, including a passport number and issuing country or an alien identification card number. It also expressly permits third-party information, subject to certification requirements.
Read the official release: FinCEN Issues Proposed Rule to Strengthen Customer Due Diligence Requirements for Covered Financial InstitutionsOur centrist perspective
For an established business opening another account at the same institution, avoiding duplicate ownership checks can reduce friction. The continuing duty to respond to unreliable information is essential: less repetition is useful only if it does not become less attention to changed circumstances.
Treasury presents the package as a way to reduce unnecessary burden and strengthen financial-crime defenses. Those are aims to test, not results established by issuing a proposal. Commenters can help distinguish the savings from codifying existing relief from the work needed to change forms, train staff and resolve identification problems.
The tradeoffs
Additional information can help an institution investigate a specific inconsistency. Broad or inconsistent requests can also increase delays and make lawful businesses harder to bank. The final approach would benefit from an understandable connection between the concern, the information requested and the decision that follows.
The ITIN restriction makes the permitted alternatives particularly important for affected owners. Third-party data may make collection easier, but it does not establish that a record is accurate. Clear procedures for resolving discrepancies would support both reliable identification and fair access.
What to watch next
- This is a proposed rule, not a final action. The release sets a comment period of 60 days after Federal Register publication; the posted notice does not supply a calendar deadline. The next useful evidence is feedback on identification alternatives, customer delays, implementation costs and the circumstances that justify collecting more information.
This is an editorial interpretation, not an official agency statement. Factual summaries rely on the linked release; implications and recommendations are our opinion. How we work
